Vol.
7, No 1 (September
2002) |
|
Urban Bodies |
|
|
|
Edited
by: |
|
Claus Dreyer and Eduard Führ
in cooperation with Gunter Gebauer and Frank Werner |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Inquiry: |
|
|
|
|
|
Claus Dreyer
Eduard Führ
Gunter Gebauer
Frank Werner |
|
The relationship between
human body and architecture has always been an elementary topic of the
theoretical discussion of Vitruv up to Le Corbusier: in the proportion
figure, in the human scale, in the model of an organism or by the idea
of a third skin or a second dress, in the determination as centre of the
sensory perception and the practical appropriation or even as aesthetic
and cultural norm, the mutual references between body and architecture
are just as various as the conclusions developed from these.
The physical human body
has formed and changed itself in its relations to architecture and town:
gestures, facial expression, disposition, social behaviour and ways of
thinking react to the built and arranged environment and are shaped by
it. However, the material body of the town and the buildings has always
been regarded as personification of ideas, images and utopias, and the
modern age has tried to show particularly the correspondence of the
architectural forms to the physiological, ergonomic and motor functions
of the human behaviour. In the historical process these relations lead
to an interaction that corresponds in continually new expressions to the
respective civilization and cultural state of an epoch.
Today one can observe the
dramatic changes of the social and cultural environments. Perhaps they
will break even apart. Moreover, one can also state the deconstruction
and the fragmentarization of the architectural body. But also the
physical appropriation of the town by different users in different ways
generates various personal urban bodies which overlay each other without
still unifying into a whole: the classic stroller or spectator interact
with the town quite differently from the yuppie or the tramp, the jogger
or the skateboarder, the prostitute or the policeman, the pensioner or
the schoolchild. These fragmentations find as material correspondences,
as various "mental maps" or mythical and utopian excesses (in sports,
films or advertising). In connection with this, a “Californization” of
the European towns which is best to be seen in the production of big
sporting events (“city marathon”) as in numerous festivals, performances
and shows, superficially reviving urban bodies.
Obviously there are not
only regional peculiarities in the interaction between the physical und
the architectural body (differences between north and south, east and
west), but also geographic and ethnographic differences that should be
explored particularly in the non-European cultures, stating the question
to what extent these differences disappear or transform themselves in
the process of globalization. It could be that the “Californization” of
the European towns is a last futile rebellion against the creeping
“disembodiment” which is also inforced by the increasing digitalization
and virtualization of the urban body. The digital networks form their
own urban structures, their artificial sensuality require a new physical
equivalent that is metaphorically grasped only unclearly by the term of
the “surfer”. In the contributions to the current
issue some of these aspects will be analyzed and interpreted more
precisely.
|
|
|
|
abstracts: |
|
|
|
|
|
Introduction |
|
|
|
|
|
___Claus
Dreyer
Detmold |
|
|
Today one can observe the dramatic changes of the social and cultural
environments. Perhaps they will break even apart. Moreover, one can also
state the deconstruction and the fragmentarization of the architectural
body. But also the physical appropriation of the town by different users
in different ways generates various personal urban bodies, which overlay
each other without still unifying into a whole.
In connection with this, one speaks of a "Californization" of the
European towns, which is best to be seen in the production of big
sporting events ("city marathon") as in numerous festivals, performances
and shows, superficially reviving urban bodies. It could be, that the "Californization"
of the European towns is a last futile rebellion against the creeping "disembodyment",
which is also inforced by the increasing digitalization and
virtualization of the urban body. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Body concepts |
|
|
|
___Jürgen Hasse
Frankfurt am
Main |
|
|
Scientific thinking about the future of our cities has an
anthropological leak. Terminological abstractionisms are forming a space
of thinking; the opposite of this is the city as a living space („gelebter
Raum“; Dürckheim). At first the article is pointing out a critique on
the actual mainstream in social science, which is proceeding on the
assumption that man lives a rationalistic life. In difference to this
view a holistic perspective on city (-development) is opened.
The aim of this argumentation forms pluralized ways to point out
intellectual critique of the city. The several kinds of thinking the
city are rooted in the bodily feeling at the places where city(life)
lives. This type of critique is not only addressed to the gnostic
concrete perception but also to the pathic performance of
perception and feeling (Erwin Straus). Political discussion on the
future of our cities
starts at first in situations of being in the urban world and not in an
area of abstractionisms and denotations of specialized languages.
|
|
|
|
___Jürgen Mick
Augsburg |
|
|
If we look
at the public space under the aspect of material movement, form and
dimension of public space are revealed to us as a physically formed
shape. The public space, we move our bodies through, is the „glue“ of
our cities, and it changes with the changes of our social lives, in that
way they do it physically.
This essay should show that the body we see in the modern age, and only
the fact that our cities are formed by the body movement, will allow us
to make conclusions, concerning our relationship with urban space today.
The searching for the new identity of our cities will lead us to our
bodies. Because the city of today, and this is the basis of my theory,
is mirroring our body as we see it today. |
|
|
|
___Thorsten
Bürklin
Karlsruhe |
|
|
While
trendy magazines show photos of smart houses and buildings that are
mostly deserted by people, man’s body – the inseparable alter ego of the
mind – remains out of question. There were only few moments in modern
architectural theory and discussion that it really was in the focus of
general interest. The suprematism of the image hides the concrete fact
that the body is. As a consequence concrete architectural space gets
lost behind its image. Instead man’s body – with all its senses – serves
as a motoric and intellectual instrument. Its spatial experiences can be
described and be read as relevant data that may be significant for
projecting public and private spaces in which we live, work or spend our
leisure time. Therefore the seemingly boring everyday experience may
be of greater importance that we usually expect it to gain. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
___Jörg
Gleiter
Berlin |
|
|
In the
delirium of the digital images of the WTC desaster architecture emerged
once again as the fundamental cultural practice of mediation
between the dominance of the image and the prevalence of the body. In
the traumatic experience of the televised catastrophe architecture
reappeared not only as a practice of intertwining the objecthood of the
city with the corporeality of its inhabitants but also as a practice of
transgression from the "pleasure of the text" (R. Barthes) and its image
quality to the "convulsion of the body" (S. Freud).
As part of a shift from architecture-as-representation to
architecture-as-performative-production today's total medialization of
everyday culture calls for a semiological reformulation of architecture
as a „technique of the body“ and origin of the „imaginative fabric of
the real“ (M. Merleau-Ponty).
However after postmodernity's "linguistic turn" and its "frivolous
signs" (M. Tafuri) and beyond classical semiotics, today the
semiological reformulation of architecture cannot but be developed in
the broader semiotic context of John Austin's concept of
performativity. In regard to architecture and its overall
medialization, but contrary to today's many attempts to reduce
architecture to a mere phenomenological event, this means asking for the
specificity of architecture as a performative practice i.e. for the
shift from the linguistic "speechact" (J. Austin) to the architectural "sketchact"
(H. Bredekamp). |
|
|
|
Bodily Practice |
|
|
|
___Bernhard
Boschert
Berlin |
|
|
This
paper deals with the new urban forms of leisure sport. A particularly
striking aspect of these sporting activities is their connection with
the conquest and reencoding of urban spaces and public squares. Whether
for inline skaters, skateboarders, beach volleyball players, streetball
players or mountain bikers, no longer do playing fields, sports
complexes or buildings constructed especially for sports take center
stage. Rather, through their activities, the city itself is discovered
as a space for movement and as a new field of action for these
alternative sport and game forms. Moreover, through the specific
movement practices of the participants, it is reconstituted as a space
with its own independent meaning. Indeed, it appears that in these new
forms of sport, various social groupings and milieus use urban spaces
and public squares to literally perform their images of
themselves and the world and to give these images physical form. In
their performative practice, the actors make themselves sensually
recognizable for themselves and others and thus try out new ways of
relating to themselves and others. |
|
|
|
___Angelika
Jäkel
Karlsruhe |
|
|
The experience and discussion of architecture as a built
surrounding of the human body is preceded by the experience of being
wrapped into clothing.
Starting with Semper, the issue of clothing in architectural theory has
long been determined by the unequal relationship between the tectonic of
structure and the ornamental of wrapping. Therefore the dimensions of
space between the human body and its clothing have been neglected, as
well as its parallels in the relationship between the body and the
spatial objects surrounding it. The influence of being tempered by
clothing on architectural experience is to be called in question – as an
underlying pattern of phenomenological space. Similarities between
architecture and clothing in the fabrics of atmosphere, the patterns of
form and the seams of making might offer transferences: How is matt
white swinging? Might a soft brown be dull and shiny at the same time?
How do we make and what do we call ‘movement’?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urban Embodiment |
|
|
|
___Ulrike
Gerhard
Würzburg
___Ingo
Warnke
Kassel
|
|
|
This
article focuses on modern cities that can be understood as almost
“artificial constructs” without organic structure or growth potential.
These so-called master-planned communities reflect actual moral concepts
of society and of the individuals of the era they were built in. The
tendency towards planned urban neighbourhoods is especially striking in
the recent urban development in the United States. By using the example
of the Washington Metropolitan Region, we will show how the concept of
space and body of the suburban city in the 20th century has changed from
the idea of a garden city (Greenbelt, MD) to the concepts of new towns
(Columbia, MD) or new urbanism (King Farm, MD). We use an
urban-geographic as well as a linguistic-semiotic approach in order to
reflect on the constitution of the semiotic construct “urban body”. The
analysis uses the concept of sign developed by Charles S. Peirce. His
dynamic semiotic helps to provide a distinctive classification of the
actual urban developments in North America and elsewhere. |
|
|
|
___Silke Kapp
Minas Gerais, Brazil |
|
|
The Brazilian culture is famous worldwide for the
relative freedom it enjoys in regard to the human body. From carnival to
football, bodies are moved, excited, exposed. This attitude runs
parallel to a way-of-life for which the external space has always been
more important than the internal space, with the city always more
important than one’s own home. What happens, then, when these habits are
changed by social violence? When certain groups retreat into the
shopping center, the car, building, or the insulated, heavily watched
boroughs, while other groups turn the older urban spaces into a sort of
battlefield? On the one hand, a cult of comfort and ’coziness’ is
introduced, but this is in principle utterly alien, and only produces
stereotyped spaces and relationships. On the other hand, the city
becomes a stage for new appropriations, a vehicle for new signs. At
first glance, this development may be considered as only negative, as an
expression of violence itself. But, when seen critically, it proves not
to be at all so unilateral. |
|
|
|
___Peter
Gotsch
Karlsruhe |
|
|
This elaboration seeks to contribute to a new understanding of space in
the informational city. It strives to re-contextualize and re-conceptionalize
space and its subsidiary elements: cities, places and in particular
bodies in the informational context in order to raise a critical
consciousness about space and in order to develop a set of implications
for spatial disciplines. Therefore my efforts can be circumscribed as an
elaboration on a re-imagination of space. The concept of imagine-a-city
evolves as a prototype of the informational city as well as a guide to
approach this city. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Historical Analysis of the Coherence between Architecture and
Materiality |
|
|
|
___Oxana
Makhneva
Yekaterinburg |
|
|
The
French architect of the 18th century Claude-Nicolas Ledoux
equated architecture with man, considering architecture as social
relations embodied in stone. Whilst speaking about architecture Ledoux
spoke about man and his spiritual aspirations that determine
architecture and are, in turn, derivatives of it. He compares a delicate
order with folds of women’s garments. A description of the decor harmony
flows harmoniously into a description of the virtues of the inspiring
muse, who also embellishes life. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Discussion of Semiotic Aspects |
|
|
|
___Alexander
Barabanov
Yekaterinburg |
|
|
A lot of research has been
carried out into the phenomenon of architecture in an attempt to reveal
the nature of its semantics. City has been compared with language,
speech, stone chronicles, theatre, etc.
Materializing in urban environment, society leaves behind its
anthropomorphic marks, which reflect direct and indirect relationships
between man and environment, between human ideas, intentions, bodies,
the human organism itself and architectural environment filled with
volumes, forms and spaces.
It is these
interrelations that manifest themselves in the interaction of the
significative and the signified, with the latter able to act both as a
denotatum and a connotatum.
References to the history of architecture from Ancient Egypt and
Antiquity to the present day are used to consider the semantics of
interaction between man and urban environment that are in the basis of
form generation in architecture and town planning. |
|
|
|
___Michael Steigemann
Bielefeld |
|
|
|
|
|
Knowledge activity is expressed by means of signs. A
problem is to outline, and the sketch images the problem. In Peirce's
thought the sketch will be called a diagram. Reasoning by the
construction of diagrams is an activity which is the paradigm for all
thinking, including creative thinking. In the 19th century the
overcoming of the crisis of art and architecture presents a unique
proceeding that can be unfolded as a construction with diagrams. Modern
views find their identity by means of refusing tradition and by means of
evoking a radical modification of composition and conception of space.
The appearance of self-experienced subjectivity and the deliverance of
pictorial representation emerge to knowledge. The diagrams demonstrate
that the modern views are reasoning about ideas and constructions that
lead to the possibility of disembodiment of classical construction of
space in the field of architecture. |
|
|
|
___Yekaterina
Barabanova
Yekaterinburg |
|
|
Different proportions of
human body are what make people so different from each other. Comparing
parts of the body, comparing the dimensions of the body with various
objects in the surrounding world man takes these proportions as a basis
for creating a new shell, i.e. architecture. This shell encloses man
from natural elements and creates a special environment – a space
controlled by man and comparable with his size.
The coarse material plane of the wall of the Romanesque cathedral
is gradually refined, covered with the tracery of flying buttresses and
becomes Gothic; the light of the stained glass replaces part of the
wall; curved stone becomes a tongue of the fire of Flamboyant Gothic;
and the wall appears to be built not of stone but of light. This is one
of the most remarkable examples of the evolution of an architectural
style. The wall gradually disappears; the shell of coarse stone is
replaced with a shell of light.
The technological revolution has provided the architect with new
materials and new technologies, enabling the implementation of most
unusual ideas. |
|
|
|
The editorial staff keeps all rights, including
translation and photomechanical reproduction. Selections may be reprinted with
reference:
Wolkenkuckucksheim, Cloud-Cuckoo-Land, Vozdushnyj Zamok
> /theoriederarchitektur/Wolke/
<
if the editorial staff is informed.
|